Public statement on new federal rule eliminating “skimming” of dues from caregivers’ Medicaid payments

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on
LinkedIn
+

Pioneer Institute applauds a new rule announced by the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) that prohibits state governments from automatically deducting union dues from Medicaid payments intended for those caring for loved ones or relatives.

Prior to this action, 13 states (including Massachusetts) classified individuals who take care of relatives and/or loved ones as public employees. A 2014 rule gave unions the ability to collect dues from Medicaid payments made to these caregivers, supposedly to provide benefits including health insurance and skills training.

In an August 2018 comment jointly submitted with other think tanks, Pioneer wrote that allowing diversion of Medicaid funds to third parties, like unions, presents risk of abuse and may result in Medicaid funds being used “for purposes not sanctioned by the Social Security Act.”

Since 2006, collective bargaining agreements in Massachusetts have authorized and subsequently required payment of dues or agency fees for all personal care attendants (PCAs) employed by Medicaid beneficiaries. Eliminating this rule allows individuals to opt into union membership and dues-paying, and disallows automatic deduction of dues on behalf of those caring for relatives or loved ones.

Many organizations involved with this issue, including Pioneer, identified that the 2014 rule allowing “dues skimming” violated the Social Security Act, which says Medicaid payments must be paid directly to caregivers. In addition, given recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions in Harris v. Quinn and Janus v. AFSCME, the 2014 rule creates a First Amendment dilemma, since mandatory payments force people to support political causes favored by unions. Individuals who don’t want to support these causes shouldn’t be forced to join the union, pay dues, or, in this case, have dues “skimmed” from Medicaid payments.

Pioneer believes the new CMS rule is a step toward giving employees the freedom to choose whether to join unions and receive the associated benefits, and ensuring that Medicaid funds of this kind are used to support caregivers and their capacity to aid elderly and disabled members of society.

Get Updates On Our Healthcare Research and Events!

Recent Research:

Payment Reform: No Government Mandate Needed

/
The move in the health sector towards payment reform took a big…

Decrease Insurance Premiums or You’ll Be Sleeping with the Fishes

/
A study released this morning may lay out the possible future…

Ryan & Rivlin on containing health care costs

/
This week's Economist has an article worth reading on the various…

Massachusetts Health Care Transparency: Bright Enough Spotlight?

/
Massachusetts officials published online this week a database…

Pioneer Senior Fellow on PBS's NewsHour

/
Pioneer's Senior Fellow on Health Care, Amy Lischko, was interviewed…

Health Care Costs Crushing States– Is the Solution to Drop out of Medicaid?

/
The headline says it all. “States' Woes Spur Medicaid Drop-Out…

Health Care in the Mid-terms: What the Polls really tell us

/
Trying to read the tea leaves of poll numbers on the general…

American as baseball, apple pie and primary care doctors?

/
Harvard Medical School recently announced an anonymous gift of…

ObamaCare blowback

/
Great piece in the Boston Globe titled "ObamaCare blowback" by…

Unresolved Safety Net Hospital Issues

/
Mr. Keefe, First, thank you for taking the time to read my post…

Next Step in Reform: Cost Control

/
The President & CEO of Associated Industries of Massachusetts…

Feds giving a safety net to Massachusetts’s safety net hospitals?

/
Two of the most prominent “safety net” hospitals in Massachusetts…

Ths is getting ugly.

/
Today’s Globe story regarding Insurance companies' unwillingness…

Unintended Consequences?

/
The Wall Street Journal reports today that the recently passed…

Crying won't help you

/
Crying won't help you, praying won't do you no good When the…