Public Statement on Nonrenewal of Keolis Commuter Rail Contract

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on
LinkedIn
+

Pioneer Institute welcomes the news that the MBTA will not renew its contract with problem-plagued commuter rail operator Keolis Commuter Services when the term ends in 2022. If the MBTA can put an effective bidding process into place for the next contract, this is a positive development for the hundred thousand-plus riders who depend on the system every day.

Since 2013, Pioneer Institute has published a steady stream of research, op-eds, blog commentary, and media appearances critical of Keolis’ performance, and calling for greater penalties for lack of performance and even re-opening the current contract. Increasingly frequent cancellations have incurred a reported $14 million in fines over the past two years, many of which have been forgiven by the MBTA, and the system has been hampered by insufficient staffing, defective equipment, and train shortages. While Pioneer, too, is impatient to see Keolis’ service improve, the Institute also opposed the MBTA’s decision to waive fines and pay the vendor an additional $66 million, on top of its $2.68 billion contract.

We are guided by a basic premise: when procuring a public service through a private contractor, the terms of the contract must be enforced – or the public suffers.

Two years ago, Pioneer Institute proposed a comprehensive fix for the MBTA, which included the establishment of a control board, and other powers. In that document, and before, Pioneer is on the record repeatedly (1) questioning the procurement process which ultimately led to only two commuter rail bidders and (2) calling for the penalty provisions of the contract to be consistently enforced.

We applaud this decision and look forward to pressing for the kind of open procurements that will attract more high-quality bidders, as well as providing insights on the type of contract that might actively promote higher quality service and the modernization of commuter rail systems, vehicles, and infrastructure.

Get Our Fix the T Updates!

Is Keolis Up to the Task?

/
The snow has melted from our streets, our fields are filled with…

Public Left in Dark on Carmen’s Union Contract

/
Background Over the past two months, Pioneer Institute has…

And What About the T’s Retirement Costs?

/
Pension and other post-employment benefit (OPEB) costs significantly…

The MBTA Commuter Rail’s Cost Structure Is Off the Rails

/
Read coverage of this report in The Boston Globe and the Boston…

Sunshine Must Return to MBTA This Spring

/
What began as a benign winter, accumulating only 2.9 inches before…

Time to Fine Keolis

/
My train was on time this morning, no T-alerts popped into my…

Commuter Parking Woes Highlight the MBTA’s Problem With Planning

/
Almost a decade after the completion of the Big Dig, the project…

The MBTA’s Problem is Not Lack of Funding

/
Background Since the mid-1990s, Pioneer has participated…

When Will Commuter Rail Return to Full Service?

/
March 30th can’t come soon enough for commuter rail riders,…

How to measure the MBTA’s operational efficiency

/
Pioneer has long been interested in the efficiency of the MBTA…

The Myth of the Underfunded MBTA

/
When the MBTA collapsed last month under the weight of snow and…

Will MBTA Win Back Riders?

/
Yesterday the MBTA Board of Directors approved a plan to compensate…

Setting the Record Straight on MBTA Expansion

/
Pioneer has previously written that rapid expansion was a…

Getting our priorities straight on the BCEC and the MBTA

/
Scot Lehigh and Shirley Leung in the Globe today both focused…

Getting our priorities straight on the BCEC and the MBTA

/
Scot Lehigh and Shirley Leung in the Globe today both focused…

New Report Outlines Massachusetts’ Experience with State Receiverships

Proposes legislation for MBTA emergency control board BOSTON…