Getting Nursing Home Care Right

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on

Pioneer Institute has long recognized that seniors deserve the best of care and that innovative policy solutions are necessary to ensure that this population enjoys a high quality of life in their later years. In the 1990s, early 2000s and most recently in 2017, the Institute dedicated Better Government Competition topics to policy issues related to aging in America. Our goal each time was to find solutions and to take advantage of new innovations that would improve the quality of life and care for the elderly.

COVID-19 has hurled intense, disproportionate and deadly challenges at seniors and their caregivers. Since the beginning of the pandemic surge in Massachusetts, Pioneer expanded its focus on nursing homes and the response of the Commonwealth to contain COVID-19 spread among seniors. We have looked at both the lack of state transparency and the substance of measures taken to contain spread. In both cases, transparency and substance, Pioneer found the Commonwealth’s response inadequately protected those in the vulnerable circumstances of long-term care facilities.

Some of our key recommendations include:

  • Oversight: Pioneer called on leaders to appoint an individual (preferably a public health expert, epidemiologist, or virologist) with sole responsibility for oversight and coordination of the responses of state agencies and nursing homes, reporting directly to the Governor.
  • Transparency: Pioneer called for increased public accessibility of data, including disclosure of COVID-19 case and death totals in absolute numbers by facility, and disclosure of whether a nursing home is accepting COVID-19 patients from hospitals.
  • Equipment: Pioneer recommended requiring nursing homes to maintain a stock of PPE (including gloves, surgical masks, N95 masks, hand sanitizer, booties, etc.), with state inspections and financing mechanisms to allow all homes to obtain it.
  • Testing: Pioneer called for regular COVID-19 point-in-time and surveillance testing among all nursing home residents and staff, including antibody testing for homes with significant outbreaks as needed.
  • Reducing spread: Pioneer urged requiring nursing homes to demonstrate their ability to form isolation units with adequate numbers of beds for infectious onslaughts as a prerequisite for continued operation.

The Boston Globe’s recent Spotlight Team coverage of COVID-19’s impact on nursing homes prominently quoted Pioneer Institute’s Barbara Anthony, who noted, “Holyoke was a microcosm.” The problem here is broad and continuing. Pioneer has been actively involved in this crucial topic from the start and will continue to advocate on behalf of Massachusetts elders and their families.

Below, we share more details about the problems identified, and the proposals prepared, by Pioneer staff around these issues. This list is illustrative, not exhaustive – and there is more to come.

  • Mary Connaughton’s April 17 blog, “Transparency Needed at Long-Term Care Facilities” was an early warning of the pandemic’s outsized impact in Massachusetts eldercare facilities, and an early call for transparency.
  • On April 20, Andrew Mikula’s blog, “Elderly People Were Already Vulnerable to COVID-19. Then it Came to Nursing Homes” again warned of the pandemic’s growing threat to Massachusetts eldercare facilities – “Senior living facilities are uniquely vulnerable to this pandemic,” it stated — and proposed concrete improvements, including staff education, isolation of residents, and reconfiguration of common areas.
  • On May 18, Greg Sullivan and Andrew Mikula’s report titled “Understaffing at Long-Term Care Facilities is Not Unique to the Holyoke Soldiers’ Home. It’s Embedded in Federal Standards diagnosed an important cause of the tragedy at the Holyoke Soldiers’ Home — weak federal staffing standards. This report received extensive coverage by, among others, the Boston Herald and MassLive, with related coverage quoting Greg Sullivan in outlets including WHDH and WCVB.
  • Barbara Anthony and Mary Connaughton’s May 20 WGBH Op-ed underscored deepening severity of the crisis, warned of “limited transparency,” and called for answers to core questions including “who in state government was/is in charge of the health and safety of long-term care facility residents and what lessons have been learned thus far?”
  • On June 2 Pioneer directly enhanced transparency, launching its online COVID Tracker for Long-Term Care Facilities, which gives the public key data from the state’s weekly public health report for 320 eldercare facilities in a user-friendly format.
  • On June 10, NECN/NBC Boston quoted Barbara Anthony on the “deplorable” failures to date, and the importance of changing course.
  • On June 28, Barbara Anthony, Mary Connaughton and Andrew Mikula issued a 7-page open letter to the legislatively-created COVID-19 Task Force about “the unique vulnerability of nursing home residents to the Coronavirus.” Among much else, it suggested 14 practical, near-term fixes including the appointment of one person with “sole responsibility” for eldercare issues. The Globe dedicated an entire article to this open letter — “Group Calls for Urgent Nursing Home Reforms Amid COVID-19” – and then ran a July 5th Editorial which focused on the letter and its “promising” recommendations, again quoting Pioneer’s Barbara Anthony.
  • August 11 brought Andrew Mikula’s account of a Pioneer records request for basic information about COVID-19 deaths among individuals with dementia in state-regulated facilities, which “potentially revealed shocking gaps in information on the facilities that the agency [DPH] oversees.”
  • David Clancy’s September 17 “A Step Backwards,” covered by the Boston Herald and the Berkshire Eagle, said the state is wrong to stop its daily reporting of cumulative data about the impact of COVID-19 on different age-groups, switching instead to weekly reports about age-group impact, based solely on the prior two weeks of data. The state should do both: report age-group impact on the basis of short-term data and cumulative data.

Get Our COVID-19 News, Tips & Resources!

Related Posts

Untangling Variants & Outbreaks: Can Vaccines & Natural Immunity Outrun Delta?

Hubwonk host Joe Selvaggi talks with author, surgeon, and public health expert Dr. Marty Makary about the COVID-19 Delta Variant, the durability of natural and vaccinated immunity, the benefits of booster shots, and the health risks for children as we move into the fall.

Why did some nursing homes experience more COVID-19 deaths and infections than others?

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused great loss for Massachusetts…

Why does a gender-gap persist in vaccination rates?

Men are more likely to die of COVID-19 than women: 13 men die…

Comparing Covid-19 Vaccination and New Infection Rates in Suffolk County: Is Vaccination Working?

Massachusetts ranks fourth nationally for the highest percent…

Dr. Babak Movassaghi on Winning in Football & Healthcare Innovation

This week on JobMakers, Host Denzil Mohammed talks with Dr. Babak Movassaghi, founder of InfiniteMD (acquired last summer by ConsumerMedical), which connects patients with top U.S. medical professionals through second-opinion video consultations, guiding patients to better care. When the world shut down due to COVID-19, Dr. Movassaghi's company was already prepared to serve patients via telehealth. In this episode, they discuss his fascinating pivot from physics and professional football in Germany, to healthcare and innovation here in the U.S., an extension of his ability to navigate multiple identities as an Iranian-German living the American Dream.

Study: Massachusetts Should Retain Additional Healthcare System Flexibility Granted During Pandemic

Massachusetts’ emergency declaration for COVID-19 ends on June 15, and with it some enhanced flexibility that has been allowed in the healthcare system.  Some of the added flexibility highlighted barriers that make the system more expensive, harder to access and less patient-centered, and the Commonwealth should consider permanently removing these barriers, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Origin of COVID-19: As Animal Source Evidence Eludes Scientists, Lab Leak Hypothesis Gains Purchase

This week on Hubwonk, host Joe Selvaggi talks with author and former New York Times science journalist Nicholas Wade about his recent article in the Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists on the possible origins of the SARS2 virus that caused the COVID-19 pandemic. In their conversation, they consider the possibility that, absent finding evidence of a natural jump from animals, the SAR2 virus may have come from a lab.

Study Calls for Better Reporting on Impact of COVID-19 in Eldercare Facilities

Over time, the Massachusetts Executive Office of Health and Human Services and Department of Public Health (DPH) have improved reporting about cases and deaths from COVID-19 in state-regulated eldercare facilities, but flaws and omissions remain and should be corrected, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Amar Sawhney on Sikhs, STEM & COVID

On this week's episode of JobMakers, host Denzil Mohammed talks to Dr. Amar Sawhney about his journey from India to Boston, and how he is using his chemical engineering background to save lives through remarkable local therapy innovations. To date, he has founded eight companies accounting for 4,000 jobs and more than $2 billion in revenue.

Massachusetts Should Disclose More Information about Its Recent Reduction in the Official Count of Long-term Care Deaths

The public -- particularly in Massachusetts, where COVID-19’s toll on elders has been so great -- has a right to know how many deaths occurred in state-regulated eldercare facilities, and how that compares to the total number of deaths. But the state's new counting standard clouds this information, and should be corrected or at least disclosed.

Preparing For Disaster: Health Readiness Expert’s Performance Review

Hubwonk Host Joe Selvaggi talks with Emergency Preparedness expert Dr. Paul Biddinger about how experts plan for disasters, and what went right and wrong in this pandemic.

COVID-19 Vaccine Tracker

Pioneer is proud to present a new vaccine tracker, the newest tool in our COVID-19 tracking project. Pioneer distilled the vaccination data down to those who are either fully vaccinated or partially vaccinated, by all the demographic categories published by the DPH. Use the new tool below to compare rates among groups, by municipality and by county. We will update the data every week.

Doctor Heal Thyself: Insider’s Prescription For Healthcare Reform

Host Joe Selvaggi talks with surgeon and New York Times bestselling author Dr. Marty Makary about the healthcare reform themes in The Price We Pay, the 2020 Business Book of the Year.  The discussion covers the value of price transparency, provider accountability, and performance information to drive better medical outcomes and improve doctor and patient satisfaction.

Patient-centered Model Outshines Insurance-centered Healthcare during Pandemic

Joe Selvaggi talks with Pioneer Institute Senior Fellow Josh Archambault about his newest research paper entitled, "Direct Health Care Agreements: A New Option For Patient-Centered Care That Costs Less and Reduces Provider Burn-out" and how this emerging service model provided its patients with comprehensive health service throughout the COVID-19 pandemic.

Study: Massachusetts Should Embrace Direct Healthcare Options

Especially in the COVID era, many are looking to alleviate the increased burden on the healthcare system.  One solution is direct healthcare (DHC), which can provide more patient-centered care at affordable prices and is an effective model to increase access to care for the uninsured, underinsured and those on public programs like Medicaid, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Pioneer Institute Statement on Governor Baker’s New COVID Restrictions

Read Pioneer Institute's public statement about Gov. Charlie Baker's new executive orders related to the state’s reopening plan that will go into effect on Nov. 6, issued in response to a significant uptick in COVID infections in Massachusetts,

Voting for Health: Party Opinions, Election Results & the Healthcare Policy Implications of Election 2020

Join Host Joe Selvaggi as he discusses with Harvard Professor Bob Blendon his New England Journal of Medicine Special Report, "Implications of the 2020 Election for U.S. Health Policy," which covers broad differences in both party’s view of the role of government in health care and what the election results will mean for Americans.

Hockey Sidelined Again

After months on the sidelines, youth hockey players across the state eagerly laced up their skates in August. Under current youth and amateur sports guidelines, locker rooms operate at 50 percent capacity, only one spectator should attend per player, and players wear masks on the bench. Unlike in MIAA high school sports, players do not wear facemasks while they play, except during faceoffs. 

Staving Off Disaster: Lessons from Covid Applied to the Epic Battle Against Drug Resistant Microbes

Join Hubwonk host Joe Selvaggi and Pioneer Institute’s Bill Smith as they discuss with inspirational public health advocate Gunnar Esiason the findings of his latest white paper, "Antimicrobial Resistance: Learning From the current health crisis to inform another."  The episode looks at the challenges to global health presented by evolving drug resistant diseases and how the lessons learned from COVID-19 could potentially save millions of lives.

Getting Nursing Home Care Right

Pioneer Institute has long recognized that seniors deserve the best of care and that innovative policy solutions are necessary to ensure that this population enjoys a high quality of life in their later years. In the 1990s, early 2000s and most recently in 2017, the Institute dedicated Better Government Competition topics to policy issues related to aging in America. Our goal each time was to find solutions and to take advantage of new innovations that would improve the quality of life and care for the elderly.