Study: Massachusetts Charters Enrolling More English Language Learners

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Share on

LinkedIn

Charter ELLs have lower attrition rates, better academic outcomes than district counterparts

BOSTON – Massachusetts charter public schools are enrolling more English language learners (ELLs) in recent years, and those students have lower attrition rates and better academic outcomes than their district counterparts, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Download

As late as 2009, ELL enrollment in Boston charter schools was just 2 percent. But a 2010 state law obligated school districts to share mailing lists with charters and required charter schools to submit detailed recruitment and retention plans for ELL students with the state Department of Elementary and Secondary Education (DESE).

“The mailing lists gave charters an effective means of recruiting English language learners,” said Dr. Cara Candal, who co-authored “Massachusetts Charter Public Schools: English Language Learners: Demographic and Achievement Trends,” with Professor Ken Ardon. “And the recruitment plans provide a way to hold charter schools accountable for enrolling more English language learners.”

By 2016, ELL enrollment in Boston charter schools jumped to 14 percent. In Gateway Cities like Lawrence, where charter ELL enrollment was already higher than in the surrounding district, that remained the case.

MIT researcher Elizabeth Setren found that by the spring of 2014, the percentage of ELLs entering Boston charter lotteries was similar to the district’s overall ELL enrollment. This suggests any remaining disparity is likely due to past enrollment patterns, and charter public schools are on a path to achieve parity with their district counterparts in the near future.

In terms of performance, 22 percent of Boston Public Schools (BPS) ELL students scored “Advanced” or “Proficient” on the 2014 MCAS, compared to 38 percent in the city’s charters.

Related news coverage: Boston Herald: Study: Charter schools boost English-language learner rolls

Read now

Setren’s 2015 study compared students who entered charter school lotteries but were not selected to students who were admitted, to test claims that charters’ success was due to attracting higher-performing students. Even with these controls, she found that ELL students in charter schools outperform their peers academically.

Setren concludes that there is no strong evidence that charter middle and high school students’ performance could be attributed to differences in background or motivation. This “selection bias” was more significant at the elementary school level, but “unlikely to explain elementary school exam results.”

Studies also find that ELL students are similarly mobile in district and charter schools, which means that student attrition does not explain charters’ results. Moreover, the rate of Boston charter students transitioning out of ELL status after one year is three times the rate at BPS.

In addition to the data, anecdotal evidence and interviews lead Candal and Ardon to suggest that frequent use of formative assessments to diagnose student needs and drive instruction, and the development of specific teacher induction programs and ongoing professional development targeted at student needs, may be among the factors responsible for charter schools’ success with ELLs.

About the Authors:

Cara Stillings Candal is an education researcher and writer. She is a senior consultant for research and curriculum at the National Academy of Advanced Teacher Education and a senior fellow at Pioneer Institute. She was formerly research assistant professor and lecturer at the Boston University School of Education. Candal holds a B.A. in English literature from Indiana University at Bloomington, an M.A. in social science from the University of Chicago, and a doctorate in education policy from Boston University.

Ken Ardon received a Ph.D. in economics from the University of California at Santa Barbara in 1999, where he co-authored a book on school spending and student achievement. He taught economics at Pomona College before moving to Massachusetts, and from 2000 to 2004, Dr. Ardon worked for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts in the Executive Office of Administration and Finance. He is a professor of economics at Salem State University, where he has taught since 2004. Dr. Ardon is a member of Pioneer Institute’s Center for School Reform Advisory Board.

About Pioneer:

Pioneer Institute is an independent, non-partisan, privately funded research organization that seeks to improve the quality of life in Massachusetts through civic discourse and intellectually rigorous, data-driven public policy solutions based on free market principles, individual liberty and responsibility, and the ideal of effective, limited and accountable government.

Get Updates on Our Charter Schools Initiative

Related Research

Constitutional amendments in 38 states born of anti-Catholic…

Part III of Pioneer Institute study series cites three approaches BOSTON…

Study: States Should Provide Parents With More Information About Homeschooling Options

June 22, 2017

Practice is growing rapidly; practitioners are becoming more…

Press Release: Pulitzer Prize Winner, Shuttlesworth Widow, & Biographer Among Participants In Forum On Civil Rights, School Choice

March 17, 2017

Update: Watch the full video clip of this event: BOSTON…

Pioneer Institute's core mission is educating the public on policy…

Study: Massachusetts Charters Enrolling More English Language Learners

Get Updates on Our Charter Schools Initiative

Pioneer Institute Files Amicus Brief Urging Supreme Court to Hear School Choice Case

State DPH Continues to Deny Private School Students Millions in School Nurse Services

Study: Financial Impact of Charter Schools Depends on Percentage of Funding Districts Receive from State

Public Statement on Alma del Mar Charter School Expansion

Study: After-School Programs Can Help Improve Flat or Declining Math Achievement

Study Finds Declining Student Achievement and Increased Harm to School Choice Since Common Core

Study Finds MA Inter-District School Choice Program a Success, but Should Be Updated

Study: MA Private & Religious School Students Denied Federally Funded Special Education Services

New Documentary Highlights Impact of Bigoted “Blaine Amendments”

Film Screenings at Area Catholic Schools to Educate Public about Barriers to School Choice

Press Release: Definitive Biographer of Pope St. John Paul II to Keynote Cristo Rey High Schools Event

Press Release: Pioneer Files Amicus Brief on Behalf of Plaintiffs in Boston Charter School Case

Extended Summer Enrichment Programs Most Effective, Cost-Efficient

Study: States Should Provide Parents With More Information About Homeschooling Options

Press Release: Pulitzer Prize Winner, Shuttlesworth Widow, & Biographer Among Participants In Forum On Civil Rights, School Choice

Study Debunks False Claims Against Charter Public School Funding and Demographics

Study: MA Charter Public Schools Have Lower Attrition Rates Than Sending School Districts

Be informed, especially today