Study: Boston-Area Communities Should Loosen Restrictions for Accessory Dwelling Units

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on

Additional units could help ease housing shortage

BOSTON—A review of 100 cities and towns around (but not including) Boston finds that loosening local zoning laws to allow for the development of more accessory dwelling units (ADUs) would help ease the region’s housing shortage without creating any significant problems, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute in partnership with the Massachusetts Smart Growth Alliance.

Accessory dwelling units are apartments within or behind owner-occupied single-family houses that appear to be single-family as opposed to two-family homes.

Thirty-seven of the 100 Boston-area communities allow ADUs and permit them to be rented out, though typically with significant restrictions.  Another 31 allow them temporarily for occupancy by relatives of the homeowner or a caretaker, and 32 have no zoning for ADUs.

New ADUs are currently created at a rate of just 2.5 per year in the 37 communities where they are permitted.  “If an average of five were added annually in each of the 100 area cities and towns, 5,000 new apartments would be created in a decade,” said Amy Dain, author of “The State of Zoning for Accessory Dwelling Units.”

Sixteen of the 37 municipalities that allow ADUs limit them to lots above a certain size.  In Manchester-by-the-Sea, lots must be at least twice the minimum size for the district.

Other communities limit ADUs by a house’s floor area.  Medfield allows them only in homes built before 1938 that cover a minimum of 2,000 square feet, while Burlington restricts them to houses that were at least 1,800 square feet as of 1989.

The median size of a new single-family home in the Northeast didn’t surpass 1,800 square feet until 1987 and didn’t top 2,000 square feet until 1992.

In the 31 cities and towns that only allow temporary ADUs for relatives or caretakers, the unit must be removed when they move out, which wastes much-needed housing.  Other apartments continue to be rented illegally, without safety inspections.

Municipal planners and housing advocates have been working for decades to increase the allowable number of ADUs.  At least 20 of the 100 communities have revised their zoning for ADUs in the last decade, yet the environment remains highly restrictive.

Since they are owner occupied, ADUs are unlikely to cause property neglect or lead to disruptive behavior such as loud parties.  New apartments would be highly dispersed and barely visible.  The 5,000 new units that could be created by loosening ADU restrictions would be spread over 538,000 single-family houses in the region.

With average household size shrinking, ADUs might maintain existing neighborhood population densities, but are unlikely to increase them.

Among Dain’s recommendations are state legislation to allow ADUs in single-family houses.  Short of a new state law, she recommends that communities allow ADUs by right rather than requiring a special permit, and that they eliminate lot size and residency restrictions (such as those limiting ADUs to members of the homeowner’s family or caretakers).

“Accessory units are environmentally smart, limited in their traffic impacts and do precious little to change the character of single-family neighborhoods,” said Pioneer Executive Director Jim Stergios. “If we are even slightly serious about increasing the supply of housing, this is a no-brainer.”

“Accessory apartments are a great way to allow homeowners to adapt to their family’s evolving needs over time while maintaining privacy and independent living,” said André Leroux, Massachusetts Smart Growth Alliance Executive Director. “They’re a great option for a young person staying at home, a caretaker for aging parents, multigenerational living, or just to help a senior homeowner cope with rising property taxes through rental income.”

About the Author

Amy Dain is currently conducting a study of residential zoning regulation in Greater Boston, commissioned by the Massachusetts Smart Growth Alliance. Previously she coordinated the StatNet initiative for the Collins Center for Public Management at UMass Boston, and managed Pioneer Institute’s Housing and Middle Cities Initiatives. She earned her Master of Public Policy from the Harvard Kennedy School of Government and Bachelor of Arts in Russian Studies from Wesleyan University.

About Pioneer

Pioneer Institute is an independent, non-partisan, privately funded research organization that seeks to improve the quality of life in Massachusetts through civic discourse and intellectually rigorous, data-driven public policy solutions based on free market principles, individual liberty and responsibility, and the ideal of effective, limited and accountable government.

About the Massachusetts Smart Growth Alliance

The Massachusetts Smart Growth Alliance (MSGA) promotes healthy and diverse communities, protects critical environmental resources and working landscapes, advocates for housing and transportation choices, and supports equitable community development and reinvestment. Its Great Neighborhoods campaign works with local residents and leaders to help cities and towns become more walkable, welcoming, and vibrant.

About the Research Study

In 2017, the Massachusetts Smart Growth Alliance commissioned a study on local regulation of residential development in eastern Massachusetts. The study is funded by a coalition of organizations including the Massachusetts Smart Growth Alliance, Citizens’ Housing and Planning Association, Home Builders & Remodelers Association of Massachusetts, Massachusetts Association of Realtors, Massachusetts Housing Partnership, MassHousing, and the Metropolitan Area Planning Council (MAPC). A committee including representatives of the organizations that provided funding, as well as municipal planners and representatives of environmental organizations, provided input into the research design. The study is a partial update of the research on local zoning regulations commissioned by the Pioneer Institute and the Rappaport Institute in 2004-2005.

Related Research & Posts:

Study Finds Supply Shortage at the Heart of Greater Boston Housing Crisis

Construction costs, land use regulation and zoning among…

Statement: Pioneer Institute in Support of Accessory Dwelling Units

Pioneer Institute Statement in Support of Accessory Dwelling…

Poor Housing Incentives: Tax Credits Reward Politicians Not Neighbors in Need

Joe Selvaggi interviews Chris Edwards, Chair of Fiscal Studies at CATO Institute, about his research on the 40-year history of Low-Income Housing Tax Credits. They delve into its features, effects, and potential alternatives that could provide greater benefits at lower costs to taxpayers.

Milton Shuts the Door
on Multifamily Housing Plans

The MBTA Communities Act, passed in 2021, provides that the 177 communities serviced by the MBTA must create multifamily zones to spur housing development close to public transportation. But the issue is an emotionally charged one, with passions high on both sides. And Milton residents in February rejected a plan to create such housing ‚ choosing a loss of some state funding over an approximately 25 percent increase in their housing stock, along with the possibility of greater congestion.

HDIP: Unintended Consequences Adding to the Housing Crisis

See how the HDIP affected the state's housing crisis. Housing prices in Gateway Cities, such as Chelsea, Revere, Everett, and Lawrence, are skyrocketing.

Barnstable County: What Towns Tax the Most?

The housing market has been the center of American economic growth…

Searching For Space: Massachusetts Real Estate in a Time of Covid

Hubwonk host Joe Selvaggi talks with real estate expert and broker/owner Pauline Donnelly about the disruption and trends created by the Covid-19 pandemic and steps buyers and renters can take to become more informed, prudent, and competitive in the frenzied market of Greater Boston and Martha’s Vineyard.

Zoning Reform Revisited: Local Control Determines How, Not If, Housing Gets Built

Hubwonk host Joe Selvaggi talks with Pioneer research associate Andrew Mikula about the need for affordable housing near the mass transit network and the requirements and local design opportunities of the 3A zoning reform law. Read Pioneer Institute's recent public comment on this topic.

Rent Control Redux: Mayor’s Committee Likely to Provide Astroturf Over Expertise

Hubwonk host Joe Selvaggi talks with Doug Quatrocchi, executive director of about the historical effects of rent control in Boston and Cambridge in the past and discuss the gap between the stated goals and the likely outcome of Boston Mayor Wu’s 25 member Rent Stabilization Advisory Committee.

Rent Control Re-Explored: What the Past Can Teach the Future

Hubwonk Host Joe Selvaggi talks with economist and MIT Professor Chris Palmer about his research and analysis of the effects of rent control in Cambridge during its 25-year implementation and in the aftermath of its repeal.

Examining Eviction Moratoriums: Testing Constitutional Limits of Executive Branch Power

Hubwonk host Joe Selvaggi talks with constitutional scholar and George Mason Law Professor Ilya Somin about the flaws and legal vulnerabilities of the first and second CDC eviction moratoriums and discuss what current and future court rulings will mean for the limits of executive agency powers.

Renters’ Unsung Heroes: Small Landlords Endure Without Income or Relief

Hubwonk host Joe Selvaggi talks with MassLandlords’ Doug Quattrochi about ways landlords faced the challenges of being caught between tenants unable to pay rent during COVID-19 shutdown and having little or no programmatic relief from state and federal agencies.