Editorial Staff

Report: Immigrant Entrepreneurs Provide Economic Benefits, but Face Significant Obstacles

/in , , /by Editorial Staff
Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on
LinkedIn
+

More likely to start innovative businesses, but getting into the U.S. is increasingly difficult

BOSTON – Immigrants have started a quarter of all businesses in Massachusetts despite making up just 17 percent of the state workforce, and those establishments appear to be more innovative than those founded by native-born Americans. Despite these contributions, shrinking federal visa caps and red tape are among the factors making it more difficult for immigrants to come to the U.S., according to “Immigrant Entrepreneurs and the Barriers They Face: An Academic Literature Review,” published by Pioneer Institute.

The innovative nature of these businesses is demonstrated by the fact that establishments with at least one immigrant founder are 35 percent more likely to hold a patent than those without an immigrant founder.

“Immigrant entrepreneurs contribute more than their share to the prosperity Massachusetts has enjoyed in recent years,” said Pioneer Executive Director Jim Stergios. “They prove every day that the American Dream is alive and well.”

Many immigrant entrepreneurs who came to this country with little money or education thrive, but their highly educated counterparts are also critical. Massachusetts is second among the states in the number of international college students per capita. Twenty-five foreign-born graduates of the Commonwealth’s colleges and universities have founded unicorn companies (private start-ups worth $1 billion or more).

But the number of international students in the U.S. has fallen every year since 2016. The pandemic certainly played a role in the recent decreases, but 60 percent of respondents to a 2019 Institute of International Education survey said the social and political environment here made them less likely to come.

“For Massachusetts to attract and retain the most talented people, we have to leverage the colleges and universities that are among our biggest economic advantages,” said Aidan Enright, who co-authored the review with Joshua Bedi.

Even more foreign-born prospective college students – 83 percent – cited the visa application process as an obstacle.

In the U.K., the average processing time to get work authorization is less than 56 days. Here, Optimal Practical Training authorizations allow foreign students studying in the U.S. to accept temporary employment in areas directly related to their field of study. OPT authorizations take between 213 and 426 days.

H1B visas allow employers to petition for highly educated foreign professionals to work in “specialty occupations” that require at least a bachelor’s degree or its equivalent. As recently as 2003, the annual cap on those visas was 191,000; today it’s 85,000. And because H1B runs a lottery system, 74 percent of applicants are rejected before their filings are even adjudicated.

In a recent CNN interview, Gov. Charlie Baker said he would like to see the federal government do something to expand eligibility for work permits to groups of asylum seekers arriving in states like Massachusetts who want to but can’t work.

Occupational licenses that often erect barriers to market entry while providing little to no quality or safety benefits can also be an obstacle for immigrant entrepreneurs. A 2022 Institute for Justice study found the licensing process for new entrepreneurs to be exceptionally burdensome in Boston.  For example, to start a food truck company an entrepreneur has to undertake 37 steps, complete 12 government forms, perform seven in-person activities, go through nine agencies, and pay nine fees costing an average total of $1,536.

About the Authors

Josh Bedi is Senior Fellow in Economic Opportunity at Pioneer Institute. He began his undergraduate career with the International Business Program at Mississippi State University and received a Bachelor of Business Administration in Business Economics and a Bachelor of Arts in German. At Mississippi State, he worked with Germany Trade and Invest as a Service Industries Intern. He earned his Ph.D. and was a Mercatus Center Fellow at George Mason University. He is now working at Copenhagen Business School as a Postdoc in Entrepreneurship at the Department of Strategy and Innovation. There, he works under the Mærsk McKinney Møller Chair in Entrepreneurship.

Aidan Enright is Pioneer’s Economic Research Associate, responsible for analyzing data and developing reports on the state’s business climate and economic opportunity. Prior to working at Pioneer, he worked as a tutor and mentor in a Providence city school and was an intern for a U.S. Senator and the RI Department of Administration. Aidan earned a Bachelor of Arts in Political Science and Economics with a concentration in U.S. national politics from the College of Wooster.

About Pioneer

Pioneer Institute’s mission is to develops and communicates dynamic ideas that advance prosperity and a vibrant civic life in Massachusetts and beyond. Success for Pioneer is when the citizens of our state and nation prosper and our society thrives because we enjoy world-class options in education, healthcare, transportation and economic opportunity, and when our government is limited, accountable and transparent. Pioneer believes that America is at its best when our citizenry is well-educated, committed to liberty, personal responsibility, and free enterprise, and both willing and able to test their beliefs based on facts and the free exchange of ideas.

Get Updates on Our Economic Opportunity Research

Related Posts:

Poll: MA Voters Oppose Legislative Proposals to Change Tax Rebate Law

A strong majority of registered Massachusetts voters oppose a plan recently announced by state legislative leaders that would change the way tax rebates are distributed in Massachusetts under a state law approved by voters in 1986, according to a new poll sponsored by Pioneer Institute and the Massachusetts High Technology Council.

Harsh Tax Policies in NY Make MA Seem Palatable as Some Residents Look to Relocate

While many Massachusetts residents relocated to either New Hampshire or Florida in 2021, a considerable amount of New Yorkers migrated into Massachusetts. Their motivation to relocate seems largely tied to the harsh taxes in New York, which surpass the rates in Massachusetts.

Massachusetts’ “Stinger” Tax, Explained

Massachusetts recognizes S Corporations as flow-through entities. However, it levies an additional "stinger" tax on shareholders of these types of entities, depending on their revenue and industry. The state should reform S Corporation tax policy because the current system is uncompetitive and nonneutral. And, in addition to the new surtax on earnings over $1 million, the stinger tax could make business owners consider relocating, which would take revenue and surtax from the state.

Changes to the Confounding Massachusetts Estate Tax

Policymakers on Beacon Hill have many visions of tax relief for this fiscal year, and all of them include changing the estate taxes. What are those changes, and what would their impact be?

An Examination of the Commonwealth Rainy Day Fund

Established in 1987, the Commonwealth Stabilization Fund has been a key component of the financial stability of Massachusetts. As of recently, it's seen spectacular growth. Why?

GDP by Industry: Middlesex County v. Suffolk County

Middlesex and Suffolk counties have contributed far more to the state's GDP than any other county in Massachusetts. However, the two differ in which industries are responsible for the greatest shares of their GDP.

The Curious Case of the Missing Stabilization Funds

Stabilization funds are a key component of a municipality's financial strength, yet many towns (including Boston!) report no stabilization funds. Why is this?

HDIP: Unintended Consequences Adding to the Housing Crisis

See how the HDIP affected the state's housing crisis. Housing prices in Gateway Cities, such as Chelsea, Revere, Everett, and Lawrence, are skyrocketing.

Large Free Cash Fund in Woburn Demonstrates Quality Financial Management

Woburn has consistently had quality financial management in recent years, demonstrated by the fact that the city had the third highest free cash fund in the state in 2020. The city’s financial success has benefited its taxpayers, as the city’s bond rating has been promoted to a AAA rating by the S&P agency standards.

Adam Ozimek: Immigration Policy Is Innovation Policy

The United States is built on all kinds of immigrants with all kinds of skills and experiences. While politicians might have us believe immigration is a divisive issue, the fact is Americans across the political spectrum agree at least on this: High-skilled immigrants are good for the country, and we need more of them.