Rigorous Civics Education Needed Now More Than Ever

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on
LinkedIn
+

This op-ed was originally published in Commonwealth Magazine.

After decades of being overlooked, the importance of teaching US history and civics in public schools is at last gaining momentum. At the same time, the American Rescue Plan will bring an influx of tens of millions of dollars into Massachusetts schools. The confluence of these two events could transform civics education, but turning potential into reality will require combining a high-quality, fact-based curriculum with strong accountability measures.

The focus on preparing students to be informed participants in American democracy is overdue. For too long, the education-as-workforce-development model has held sway in the United States, despite research and outcomes evidence showing that it falls short in terms of both academics and economics.

The newfound focus on civics also has the potential to be a much-needed unifying force in our bitterly divided country. Unfortunately, the approach taken by the biggest players in this space would likely have the opposite effect.

The organization Generation Citizen takes a highly partisan “action civics” approach, while iCivics, another nonprofit working in this area, promotes “video game civics.” If there’s anything we’ve learned from the workforce training era in K-12 education, it’s that in addition to degrading academic quality, the focus on supposedly useful soft skills actually leaves students less prepared to succeed both in the workplace and in our democracy.

Rather than attempting to inculcate students in a particular ideology, combining a high-quality, fact-based curriculum with strong accountability measures is the best way to equitably develop informed citizens who possess the civic knowledge needed to be continuous learners.

That’s what we did in 1993, when a Democratic Legislature and a Republican governor worked together to craft an education reform law that called for teaching the Federalist Papers, founding documents, US, Massachusetts and labor history. It also called for creation of a US history MCAS test that, like the English, math, and science tests, students would have to pass to graduate from high school.

Unfortunately, for over 25 years the Commonwealth has brushed aside these aspects of state law. In an era of strong anti-testing sentiment, it’s important to remember that MCAS didn’t create class- and race-based disparities; it shone a light on them, making policy makers more likely to address them. MCAS is central to the Bay State’s historic successes on virtually every measure of student achievement.

As part of the anti-testing backlash, the Patrick administration decided in 2009 to postpone implementation of the history MCAS, citing the cost (at the time, less than $2.5 million). The current flow of federal dollars obviates that concern.

Since that time, the Commonwealth has also dumbed down its formerly nation-leading US history standards – with the guidance of iCivics and Generation Citizen. The growing interest in K-12 civics combined with an increase in federal aid provides an opportunity to correct this mistake and match history and civics standards with a US history MCAS test.

Recent proposals to resuscitate civics have come from the federal government, such as the proposed Civics Secures Democracy Act. While we appreciate the awareness of the issue Washington, DC, has demonstrated, education is best addressed by the states. State and local governments provide more than 90 percent of funding for K-12 public education in the US.

In addition, the debacle of the Common Core State Standards and national testing associated with it have, over the last decade, demonstrated why the federal government is ill-suited to solve these problems. What started as an effort to ensure that all states adopt rigorous English and math standards turned into a “race to the middle.” This resulted in high-performing states like Massachusetts ending up with inferior standards and lower student performance.

Public education steeped in the liberal arts promotes tolerance and respect for the rule of law, while guarding against the decline in civil discourse that is doing such great harm to our nation.

The Commonwealth has a chance to realize these important goals and seize on the confluence of federal funding and a newfound awareness of the importance of teaching history and civics. Success – and achieving the founders’ goal of a public school system that prepares students to be active participants in American democracy – will require Massachusetts policy makers to focus on facts and academic rigor backed up by meaningful accountability.

Tom Birmingham is a former president of the Massachusetts Senate, co-author of the Massachusetts Education Reform Act of 1993, and a senior fellow in education at Pioneer Institute.

Get Updates on Our Education Research

Related Posts

Tax credit scholarship program would give Catholic schools fighting chance

/
I am among the countless individuals whose lives have been shaped by Catholic education; in my case, it was attending high school at Austin Prep. Despite a stellar record, Catholic schools are facing a grim financial picture. But a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision gives new hope to the schools and to the many Massachusetts families with children who would benefit from attending them.

Tax Credits, Religious Schools And You

/
Six years ago, I met with Erica Smith of the Institute for Justice in a Montana coffee shop, where I agreed to be the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit about the use of funds from a state education tax credit program for children attending religious schools. This past June, in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed Montana’s highest court and ruled that if parents use funds from the program to access private education, religious school options cannot be excluded.

Voc-tech schools thriving despite pandemic strictures

/
HANDS-ON EDUCATION plays a critical role at Massachusetts regional vocational-technical high schools, where students alternate weekly between academics and shop classes. Given that reality, you’d think the schools would be particularly hard hit by the switch to hybrid models under which students are in a physical school building only half the time. But thanks to innovative approaches to coping with pandemic-related restrictions, voc-techs are successfully bucking statewide public-school enrollment trends.

Education tax credits don’t cost taxpayers a cent

/
This op-ed has appeared in WGBH News, The Providence Journal,…

MCAS testing essential to address falling test scores

/
Amid the chaos that was created by schools suddenly being shuttered in March as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic, it made sense to cancel administration of Massachusetts Comprehensive Assessment System (MCAS) tests. But supporters of pending legislation that would place a four-year moratorium on using MCAS as a high school graduation requirement and create a commission to study alternatives to the tests are no longer responding to a crisis; they are using it to advance their anti-reform agenda.

When ignorance and violence are permitted to trump justice

/
This week marks the 65th anniversary of the murder of Emmett Till, a 14-year old black boy from Chicago who was killed by two white Mississippians for whistling in the presence of a white woman.