Study Calls for Tying Additional State Education Aid to Reforms

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on
LinkedIn
+

Narrowing funding gap between high-income and less affluent districts should be focus of school funding formula update

Contact Jamie Gass at jgass@pioneerinstitute.org

Read coverage of this report in The Boston Globe and the Springfield Republican.

BOSTON – Efforts to update the Commonwealth’s K-12 education funding formula should focus on narrowing the gap between affluent and low-income school districts and be accompanied by reforms designed to improve student outcomes and enhance accountability, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

“Tying new money to high standards and accountability was the grand bargain at the heart of the Commonwealth’s successful 1993 Education Reform Act,” said Jamie Gass, director of Pioneer’s Center for School Reform, who co-authored “The Next Chapter of Education Funding in Massachusetts” with Gregory Sullivan and Charles Chieppo. “Policymakers should not forget that important lesson.”

Beginning in 1993, the Commonwealth’s SAT scores rose for 13 consecutive years. State scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) shot up, too. By 2005, Massachusetts students became the first to score best in the nation in all four major NAEP categories (fourth- and eighth-grade reading and math).

While American students as a whole lag behind their international peers, 2007 and 2011 Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study results showed that Massachusetts students were competitive with their counterparts in places like Japan, South Korea and Singapore. In 2007, Bay State eighth graders even tied for first place internationally in science.

Over the last decade, Massachusetts has retreated from key reforms that drove gains in student achievement. The Commonwealth has adopted weaker academic standards in English, math, science and history, transitioned to the watered-down MCAS 2.0, eliminated an independent district accountability agency, and seen legislative support for proven innovations like charter public schools erode.

As a result, state SAT and MCAS scores have declined, and Massachusetts is among a minority of states in which NAEP scores fell between 2011 and 2017.

Among the authors’ recommendations are new models for underperforming and the lowest-performing school districts, reconstituting an independent school district audit function and funding an MCAS graduation requirement in U.S. history, as was included in the 1993 Education Reform Act.

The authors also call for investing in effective urban school models by fully funding district charter school reimbursements and making funding for charter school facilities more equitable. They urge more funding for METCO and regional vocational-technical high schools, along with expanding those programs if possible.

Funding

From 1993 to 2019, state aid to schools (known as Chapter 70 funding) jumped by over 227 percent. During the same period, school spending by municipalities rose by about 157 percent, while the consumer price index for Boston-Cambridge-Newton increased by around 84 percent and statewide public-school enrollment went up about 16 percent.

Today, Massachusetts ranks eighth among the states and Washington, D.C. in total per-pupil spending. The Commonwealth is fourth among the states in per-pupil funding from local sources and 11th in state support.

The study finds that the generally accepted narrative that the Chapter 70 funding formula hasn’t changed in over 25 years is not true. In fiscal 2007, important changes were made in the way the Commonwealth determines a municipality’s ability to contribute to its education costs. We are currently in the midst of a seven-year phase-in of a plan to more accurately reflect school district health insurance costs.

The area in which the formula has failed to keep up is seen in the growing gap between high-income and less affluent school districts. The evidence is clear that progressive funding is effective, especially given that low-income students are generally more expensive to educate.

While high-income districts often receive between $1,500 and $4,000 annually in per-pupil state aid, compared to $10,000 to $12,000 for the lowest-income districts, large property tax bases allow high-income districts to provide generous local funding.  In 2018, for example, Cambridge contributed $25,920 per pupil.

Low-income districts provide far less from local funds. For example, Lawrence provided $1,563 per pupil and Springfield $2,403 in local funds per pupil in 2018. The net result is that while lower income communities receive disproportionately higher state aid, their total per-pupil funding is far less than that of higher-income communities. Lawrence’s total 2018 per-pupil spending was $14,899, while Cambridge’s was $29,478.

As lawmakers seek to address these funding gaps, they should keep in mind the enormous parallel funding challenges they will face in coming years. For example, the Commonwealth is responsible for the unfunded liability of the Massachusetts and Boston Teachers Retirement Systems. Taken together, these systems account for nearly two thirds of the state’s overall $41.66 billion unfunded pension liability. The unfunded liability for the two systems increased at an annualized rate of nearly 12.5 percent between 2000 and 2018.

To make matters worse, funding schedules to pay down the unfunded liability are invariably backloaded more and more over time, which puts off addressing the problem. “The most recent schedule calls for the Commonwealth to contribute nearly $7 billion in fiscal 2036, which is clearly unrealistic,” Sullivan said.

The authors conclude that the goal of making state education funding more equitable by increasing aid to low-income districts can be achieved through increases such as those proposed by Gov. Baker, who would raise Chapter 70 aid by about $1.25 billion, or about 21 percent, by fiscal 2026. Proposals such as the Promise Act, which would add about twice as much over seven years, would add more than is needed to effectively update the formula.

About the Authors:

Gregory Sullivan is Pioneer’s Research Director, and oversees PioneerPublic and PioneerOpportunity. Prior to joining Pioneer, Sullivan served two five-year terms as Inspector General of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

Charles Chieppo is a senior fellow at Pioneer Institute and the principal of Chieppo Strategies LLC, a public policy writing and communication firm.

Jamie Gass is Pioneer Institute’s Director of the Center for School Reform.

About Pioneer:

Pioneer Institute is an independent, non-partisan, privately funded research organization that seeks to improve the quality of life in Massachusetts through civic discourse and intellectually rigorous, data-driven public policy solutions based on free market principles, individual liberty and responsibility, and the ideal of effective, limited and accountable government.

View more information, including an interactive map and data tables on Chapter 70 funding.

Stay Connected!

Book Finds Massachusetts Voc-Tech Schools Are National Model, Calls for Expansion

Massachusetts vocational-technical schools -- boasting minuscule dropout rates, strong academic performance, and graduates prepared for careers or higher education -- should be expanded to meet growing demand, according to a new book published by Pioneer Institute.

METCO Works Well, Small Tweaks Could Make It Even Better, Study Says

The Metropolitan Council for Educational Opportunity, or METCO program, has successfully educated thousands of students for 56 years, but several minor changes could make it even better, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Pioneer Institute Statement on the Latest State Audit of the Boston Public Schools

The third review of the Boston Public Schools (BPS) in fewer than 20 years makes clear: Things are getting worse.  Graduation rates are down, achievement gaps are up, an unacceptably large percentage of students attend schools ranked in the lowest 10 percent statewide. In a cruel twist, more than three in five students still are not taught material on which they are tested. There remains no clear strategy for improvement.  

Study Finds Continued Growth in Education Tax-Credit Scholarship Programs

Education tax credits grew increasingly popular in 2021, with four more states enacting programs.  There are now 28 tax-credit scholarship (TCS) programs in 23 states, and they serve more than 325,000 students, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Study Recommends State Receivership for Boston Public Schools

After 15 years of rapid decline marked by low overall performance, yawning achievement gaps, instability, bureaucratic inertia and central office ineffectiveness in the Boston Public Schools (BPS), the Commonwealth should initiate receivership of the district, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

New Study Shows What Works for Civics Education

Americans strongly disagree about how our K-12 schools should teach our system of self-government. Dozens of organizations offer rival civics education resources and many of them don't work. A new study published jointly by Pioneer Institute and the National Association of Scholars offers in-depth evaluations of 15 leading civics programs, grades them on their effectiveness, and offers recommendations for how Americans should build upon these programs.

Study Finds Massachusetts Would Benefit from Adopting Education Savings Accounts

Massachusetts provides fewer options for students to be educated outside their assigned school districts than most other states do, and educational savings accounts (ESAs) offer an effective tool for giving students additional opportunities, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Virtual Learning Grows During COVID

Virtual learning in K-12 education continues to grow due to the health threat caused by coronavirus variants and the assistance this learning model can provide to at-risk students, according to two papers released today by Pioneer Institute.

Pioneer Institute Files Amicus Curiae Brief in U.S. Supreme Court School Choice Case

Pioneer Institute has filed an amicus curiae brief in Carson v. Makin urging the Supreme Court of the United States to strike down a provision of Maine law. The Court will hear oral arguments in Carson this morning (December 8) at 10 am. The Maine law being challenged allows districts that don’t have their own schools to contract with a school or pay for students that choose to attend public or private schools, but explicitly excludes religious schools.

Study: After Years of Steady Increases, Homeschooling Enrollment Rose Dramatically During COVID

After steadily increasing for years, the number of parents choosing to homeschool their children skyrocketed during the pandemic, and policy makers should do more to acknowledge homeschooling as a viable option, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

Poll Finds Mixed Views About Schools’ Pandemic Performance

A year into the COVID-19 pandemic, Massachusetts residents have mixed opinions about how K-12 education has functioned, but they tend to view the performance of individual teachers more favorably than that of institutions like school districts and teachers’ unions, according to a poll of 1,500 residents commissioned by Pioneer Institute.

Study: Systemic Failure in IDEA Implementation for Private School Students with Disabilities in Additional States

On the heels of a $3.8 million settlement for private school students with disabilities in Massachusetts for the state’s failure to comply with provisions of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) that require provision of equitable, publicly funded special education services to students in private schools, a Pioneer Institute study finds that two states and three school districts around the country for which data are available also appear to be out of compliance.

Key Madison Park Program Lags Other State Voc-Techs, but Shows Signs of Improvement

The co-operative education program at Boston’s Madison Park Technical Vocational High School, which places students in paid positions with local employers, lags far behind other Massachusetts vocational-technical schools in terms of both placements and number of employer contacts.  But with the school as a whole beginning to improve after years of turmoil, the co-op is also showing promising signs, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

New Book Offers Roadmap to Sustainability for Massachusetts Catholic Schools

Catholic schools in Massachusetts must focus on the characteristics that make them academically successful and distinguish them from traditional public schools, but must also seek new models and governance structures that will help them achieve financial sustainability, according to a new book published by Pioneer Institute. The book, "A Vision of Hope: Catholic Schooling in Massachusetts," will be the topic of a webinar co-sponsored by Pioneer and the Catholic Schools Foundation to be held on Wednesday, January 27 at 2:00 pm. 

New Study Provides Toolkit for Crafting Education Tax-Credit Scholarship Programs

In the wake of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that struck down a key impediment to private school choice, Pioneer Institute has published a toolkit for designing tax-credit scholarship programs. Now available in 18 states, nearly 300,000 students nationwide use tax-credit scholarships to attend the school of their family’s choice. TCS policies create an incentive for taxpayers to contribute to nonprofit scholarship organizations that aid families with tuition and, in some states, other K–12 educational expenses. This paper explores the central design features of TCS policies—such as eligibility, the tax credit value, credit caps, and academic accountability provisions—and outlines the different approaches taken by the TCS policies in each state.

Study: Signs of Progress at Madison Park, but Still a Long Way to Go

Four years after it began to implement a turnaround plan, Boston’s Madison Park Technical Vocational High School is showing clear signs of progress, but its performance continues to lag behind that of other vocational-technical schools in Massachusetts, according to a new study published by Pioneer Institute.

MA’s Remote Learning Regs Should Specify Consistent District Grading Policies, Return of MCAS in 2020-21

The COVID-19 pandemic-related revisions to Massachusetts’ remote learning regulations should restore state and local accountability by specifying that any remote academic work shall, to the same extent as in-person education, prepare students to take MCAS tests, and that grading criteria should be the same across in-person, remote, and hybrid learning environments, according to a new policy brief published by Pioneer Institute.

New Pioneer Study Looks to International Examples to Inform Massachusetts K-12 Schools Reopening

With the fall semester fast approaching, Massachusetts should provide more specific COVID-19-related guidance for school districts about ramping up remote learning infrastructure; rotating in-person cohort schedules; diversifying methods of communication between students, parents, and teachers; and investigating physical distancing capabilities.  Districts must determine whether to adopt in-person, remote, or hybrid schooling options, and they will not be ready for the fall unless the state provides clear direction, according to new analysis from Pioneer Institute.