Mass Open Books
Your Money. Your Government.
Valuable tools and resources to help you navigate Massachusetts public policy.
Your Money. Your Government.
Community Solutions
Know Your Schools
A Citizen’s Resource
Reports, Media, Videos, and More.
Understanding Retirement Benefits
Saved by the Nanny State!
/0 Comments/in Blog, News /by Steve PoftakYesterday’s Globe brought news of an initiative by the City of Boston to move folks out of emergency rooms and into Community Health Centers, for treatment of non-acute conditions. That’s a laudable goal, but it brings to mind the inconsistency of the city’s full-throated opposition to another group of non-acute healthcare providers just a few years back. Back in 2008, the mayor warned of dire consequences, saying that permitting these health care providers to operate “jeopardizes patient safety” and that they “will seriously compromise quality of care and hygiene.” As a result, Boston didn’t get any MinuteClinics. Lots of other Massachusetts communities (including Newton, Braintree, Quincy, Cambridge, and Medford) have them. Did you miss the stories about the utter collapse […]
Handwaving away opposition to the national standards
/1 Comment/in Blog, Blog: Common Core, Blog: Education, Jim Stergios, News, Related Education Blogs /byPeriodically, over at the Fordham blog, Checker Finn does his best imitation of the cop waving traffic through at the scene of the car crash we like to call Common Core. In a post last week (“The war against the Common Core”), he morphs into good ol’ Sergeant Finn, crabbing at any observers, “Nothing to see here, folks. Move along, move along.” The mishaps around Common Core national standards are simple driver misjudgment, he explains. Steering mistakes. Nobody’s breaking the law. And don’t worry, because even though there have been lots of accidents, the road ahead is not dangerous. This is classic Checker handwaving, passing off politics as policy. Let’s look at the four arguments he makes. 1. Don’t worry […]
Massachusetts Dreams of Kick-starting a New Economy With Solar
/0 Comments/in Blog, Transparency /by Michael Morisy“I’ve said all along, if Massachusetts can get clean energy technology right, the world will be our customer. Evergreen Solar is one of the companies that’s going to help us get clean energy right. I am proud that my economic development and energy and environmental affairs teams were able to help Evergreen Solar grow and thrive right here in Massachusetts, and give us a head start toward building a clean energy economy.” – Governor Deval Patrick, April 17, 2007 Press Release In previous posts, I’ve looked at why Massachusetts failed to see looming problems with Evergreen Solar and how competition with other bidders drove state employees to scramble to appease Evergreen negotiators . Another narrative arc also helps explain why […]
Understanding Obamacare’s Essential Health Benefits for MA: Square Peg in a Round Hole?
/0 Comments/in Blog, Blog: Healthcare, Healthcare /byThe Affordable Care Act (ACA) requires insurers to provide an essential health benefits package (EHB). ACA legislation identifies ten general categories of mandated coverage (see right hand side below). A recent HHS informational bulletin outlined the scope of EHB in any given state must be equal to: One of the three largest small group plans in the state by enrollment; One of the three largest state employee health plans by enrollment; One of the three largest federal employee health plan options by enrollment; The largest HMO plan offered in the state’s commercial market by enrollment. States will need to spend a significant amount of time deciding what “benchmark typical employer plan” they would like to use, or HHS will select […]
Psst. Hey MBTA, Could You Use $60 Million?
/0 Comments/in Blog, News /by Steve PoftakI had the pleasure of doing Bradley Jay’s radio show on WBZ a few weeks back. We talked about the MBTA, but what really lit up the phone lines was our discussion of potential savings from reform of the T’s Ride paratransit program. Most of the callers were concerned that eligibility reforms would take away their transportation. But it appears that the MBTA could save a lot of money just by restructuring the service, before even dealing with eligibility issues. The state’s Inspector General has come out with a report that analyzes the Ride alongside other paratransit programs operating within in the state and determined that a key difference in business practices between the Ride and other paratransit providers results […]
“Removing the Barriers: Virtual Schools & State Regulations” (March 1, 2012)
/0 Comments/in Blog, News, Video, Video - Virtual Schools, Videos, Videos - Virtual School /byOn March 1st, 2012, Pioneer welcomed education experts from across the country: Susan Patrick, CEO of the International Association for K-12 Online Learning; Hanna Skandera, New Mexico Secretary of Education; Julie Young, President of Florida Virtual School; Healther Staker, Innosight Institute; as well as Martha Walz, Massachusetts State Representative; Michael Sentance, former New England Administrator, U.S. Department of Education; and Will Fitzhugh, Founder and Editor, The Concord Review. They discussed regulatory barriers to digital learning. Susan Patrick, CEO of the International Association for K-12 Online Learning: [youtube height=”HEIGHT” width=”WIDTH”]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyHgLQSjZ9U&feature=youtu.be[/youtube] Hanna Skandera, New Mexico Secretary of Education: [vimeo height=”HEIGHT” width=”WIDTH”]https://vimeo.com/43176807[/vimeo]
What Exactly is the MBTA’s “Big Dig Debt”?
/2 Comments/in Blog, News /by Steve PoftakThe back-and-forth over the MBTA finances has seen a great deal of attention to the MBTA’s $5.2 billion in debt. A portion of that debt has been tagged with the nearly toxic label ‘Big Dig Debt’, and it’s important to be precise about what that actually means. The MBTA’s debt comes from three sources — $1.85 billion from spending since the 2000 start of forward funding, $1.65 billion that was transferred to the MBTA under forward funding and was related to previous transit projects, and $1.7 billion in funding for projects mandated under a Big Dig-related agreement. (N.B. All above figures are from the MBTA Advisory Board’s Budget and Fiscal Analyst Brian Kane’s invaluable Born Broke report. Kane, of course, […]
Mandatory Volunteerism
/0 Comments/in Blog, Blog: Common Core, Blog: Education, Jim Stergios, News, Related Education Blogs /byThe last decade has seen an explosion in the number of middle and high schools mandating volunteerism. I am not a fan of forcing volunteerism, and “mandatory volunteerism” offends those who treasure meaningful language. But within a set of courses and activities aimed at rounding out children so that they will become effective participants in civil society, such requirements may make sense. That is especially so if students can choose the volunteer program and not be restricted to school-approved activities. Choosing what you are passionate about is critical to being a good citizen. Clearly, such mandates are not things we impose on adults. Which is why it is so disconcerting to see the federal department of education treat state and […]
Are Turnaround Schools Just Spin?
/0 Comments/in Blog, Blog: Education, Blog: School Choice, Jim Stergios, News, Related Education Blogs /byThe waiver from the federal No Child Left Behind Act will, as noted yesterday, have a number of effects, with three big ones being: It moves the goalposts for accountability back years (at least 2017, more likely 2024) and weakens the accountability goal (from proficiency for all students to making progress on the achievement gap) It gets rid of all of the law’s school choice and parental options, which were to kick in after a number of years of continued school failure It centralizes innovation and change strategies in Malden (the world HQ of the state department of education) The first effect listed above is a simple punt on accountability. But the last two bullets mark a move away from […]
Moving the Goalposts on NCLB
/0 Comments/in Blog, Blog: Common Core, Blog: Education, Jim Stergios, News, Related Education Blogs /byMassachusetts and nine other states made news last week by seeking and receiving waivers from major provisions of the federal No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB). The waiver was never a favorite of mine but I think the way it was upended and why says a lot about the centralizing worldview of federal and state policymakers. First thing is to separate process and substance. The process on the waivers is wrongheaded—and likely illegal. Stay tuned for more on that. On the substance, US Department of Ed Secretary Arne Duncan outlined the key requirements he wanted Massachusetts to fulfill, on standards (what Sec. Duncan calls college- and career-readiness standards), instruction and leadership, and accountability. On standards, Massachusetts met the feds’ requirement […]
Hold the Cork for The Connector
/0 Comments/in Blog, Blog: Healthcare, Healthcare /byThe Connector made a “big” announcement about the Business Express program today– that all carriers are now selling in the exchange. But a little context is needed before we throw a party. In a September 2010 paper, I addressed the limited benefit of the Business Express program in the Connector. …Business Express (BE) also suffers from design limitations and does little to address the underlying reasons behind premium increases. It does reduce the monthly fee that small employers typically pay to third-party administrators from $35 per subscriber to $10 per subscriber, saving employers roughly $300 per employee per year. However, this reduced fee is not unique to the Connector. The Massachusetts Business Association contends that it offers a similarly low-priced plan. […]
Case of the Missing State Reports
/0 Comments/in Blog, Blog: Healthcare, Healthcare /byThe Division of Health Care Finance and Policy (DHCFP) plays an important role in the Bay State with their regular data reports. This data helps policymakers and those outside government plan and adjust to changes in the market. So, I have been wondering for months why DHCFP has fallen way behind releasing a number of regular reports. For example, a Key Indicators report was due in December 2011. This is a quarterly report that the Division has released religiously for years. The last report on-line is from May. What gives?
Driving Costs at Boston Public Schools
/0 Comments/in Blog, News /by Steve PoftakEducation spending is one of those things that makes everyone feel good — we all want the best for kids, right? But that good feeling begins to fade when you see that many of the drivers of increased spending aren’t directly related to classrooms. In the (laudably detailed) proposed budget for FY13, Superintendent Johnson notes that health insurance is flat for the upcoming year but will increase by $7.7m in FY14 (on a base of $127.7m in total benefit spending). As noted in a 2010 research report, spending on health benefits increased by more than the increase in state education aid from 2000 to 2007. In other words, all the additional tax dollars the state spent on education during that […]
A Halfhearted School Budget in Massachusetts
/0 Comments/in Blog, News, Related Education Blogs /by Jim StergiosYou know you’re in for trouble when a school district with major graduation and dropout rates problems announces a new budget and leads with the hiring of five new nurses. That is not the definition of urgency. The big new Boston budget of $856 million came with big headlines about more nurses and an overhaul of Roxbury’s Madison Park Vocational Technical High School. $856 million for about 54,000 students. That breaks down to almost $16,000. Of course it does not include additional funding sources and is not the complete picture. Last year’s NCES estimates pegged Boston as the most expensive urban school district in the country, clocking in at around $21,000 per student. There is an obvious problem with the […]
Manufacturing’s Moment?
/0 Comments/in Blog, News /by Steve PoftakManufacturing has a bad image these days. For those of us inside Route 128 , it can feel like there’s nothing left. But the reality for the rest of the state is very different. Manufacturing still employs approximately 260,000 people or 8% of the workforce. And these people are working in good jobs at good wages – in the areas where manufacturing is still going on, wages in the industry are above the area median. If you’d like to know more about manufacturing in Massachusetss, I’d encourage you to look at work by the state’s Commonwealth Corporation and Northeastern’s Barry Bluestone. With Obama’s State of the Union, there’s increased attention to the industry. (I’m happy to see the attention paid […]