Home News

Vitamin Parents Part 2: Twin Moms Converting a Decent Traditional School Experience Into a “Wow” Homeschool One

This episode of Homeschooling Journeys features Andreina, twin sister of Mariana, who was interviewed last week.  They’re from Venuezuela, and moved to the USA for college.  Each has two kids, living in Florida.

Andreina is spending her ESAs on: jujitsu competition and instruction; School of Rock (bass and drums); Surf Skate Science.

Curious Mike describes them as “Vitamin Homeschoolers” – they see homeschooling as a way to enhance their children’s education rather than addressing any major issues with traditional schooling.

Listening to Andreina, I mentally compared her experience to that of traditional teachers.

1. The “Work From Home” vibe versus Teacher Narrating Each Task

Andreina says: “I give them a list of things that they’re supposed to do on their own.  So they do math (Beast Academy), they decided they wanted to learn a second language, so they do a little bit of Portuguese every day.  Independent reading, and they practice their music.  And then they help with things in the house. And then we do certain things as a group, like a read aloud curriculum that we have.  My husband started doing some project with them of creating website, and doing a new business with them.”

The kids go and find Mom or Dad if they need help, interchangeably.  Andreina holds the kids accountable.

2. Teacher Observation

Andreina has a luxury – “peer observation” of her homeschool teaching with her twin.  They sometimes get all four kids together for “Family Co Op.”  So the opportunities to comment on each other’s teaching style flows naturally.

As a professional culture, I don’t see much peer observation (yet) in homeschooling.  Facebook posts request advice.  But almost nobody describes videotaping their dining room table homeschool teaching for, say, 10 minutes, and then sending to a trusted friend for feedback.

Some classroom teachers get frequent observational feedback, perhaps from peers.

I hypothesize that if peer observation could become part of homeschool culture, kids would be better off.  There’s a big difference between describing oneself what YOU think is happening in your homeschool, versus letting the video/audio tell the story.

3. Student Motivation: Every Dog Has His Bone

Motivation challenges homeschool and traditional teachers alike.

For Andreina, she varies incentives, to things that happen to be working at the time for her son or daughter.  She says:

“My father in law has this saying, I’ll translate it from Spanish, ‘Every dog has their bone.’  My son is motivated by getting extra ipad time.  For my daughter, screen time wasn’t that much of an incentive for her.   She’ll read a lot because she loves reading, she’ll focus on the independent reading, but then she won’t do her math.  But for her, she loves chocolate, if you do two of your tasks then you can get one chocolate chip from the freezer.”

Here classroom teachers are at a disadvantage.  They do the best they can with whole class incentives, but inherently, that doesn’t line up well with variation in motivation….ie., they can’t easily create/choose a different “bone” for each kid.

There is, however, a tradeoff!  Kids see the homeschool teacher first as Parent – with all of those dynamics – and so the homeschool parent gives up the “authoritative status” that many kids have for classroom teachers.  Kids who wouldn’t push back on a classroom teacher may do that for a homeschool teacher.

Tell us what you liked and didn’t about the episode!  You can email me at MGoldstein@pioneerinstitute.org.